| Saturday, March 3, 2012 | |||||
| Away Team | Pick % | Pick % | Home Team | ||
| West Virginia | 100% | 0% | South Florida | ||
| #9 Georgetown | 50% | 50% | #10 Marquette | ||
| Alabama | 100% | 0% | Mississippi | ||
| #17 Louisville | 0% | 100% | #2 Syracuse | ||
| Arkansas | 50% | 50% | Mississippi State | ||
| #7 North Carolina | 0% | 100% | #5 Duke | ||
| #13 Baylor | 100% | 0% | Iowa State | ||
| #24 San Diego State | 100% | 0% | TCU | ||
| Wyoming | 0% | 100% | #21 UNLV | ||
| Sunday, March 4, 2012 | |||||
| Away Team | Pick % | Pick % | Home Team | ||
| #1 Kentucky | 100% | 0% | #12 Florida | ||
| Illinois | 0% | 100% | #16 Wisconsin | ||
| #25 Virginia | 100% | 0% | Maryland | ||
| #8 Ohio State | 50% | 50% | #6 Michigan State | ||
| California | 50% | 50% | Stanford | ||
| Purdue | 0% | 100% | #23 Indiana | ||